(This is Part Two of a four-part series examining the allegations against Oren and Alon Alexander, the fake blog that seeded a decade of rumors, and the legal campaign that followed.)
The torrent of allegations against Oren and Alon Alexander started with a single accusation.
In March 2022, a woman named Kate Whiteman filed a Summons with Notice in the Supreme Court of New York, publicly naming the brothers as defendants and accusing them of sexually assaulting her at a party in the Hamptons in May 2012. That filing became the foundation on which everything else was built: a second lawsuit filed by a woman who could not specify the date of her alleged incident and whom the brothers say they have never met, a demand that eventually reached $50 million, the resurrection of a fake blog post that a court had already determined was fabricated, and a public media campaign that drew on all of it. Whiteman’s accusation was the original charge. What followed was the pile-on.
Whiteman tragically passed away in late 2025. Her death adds a profound weight to this story, and whatever her internal struggles or motivations may have been, her passing is a tragedy. But the legal campaign launched in her name, and the way it weaponized a fabricated internet rumor, remains a matter of public record that has never been fully examined.
The lawsuit, filed a decade after the alleged incident, described a woman whose life had been shattered by the Alexanders. But that narrative ran into an immediate problem: it was contradicted by a mountain of contemporaneous evidence.
By the time the legal campaign reached its peak, Whiteman’s attorneys were demanding $50 million from the brothers. That figure did not appear in the original filing. It grew. The initial demand, submitted through Whiteman’s first law firm, sought $35 million as a settlement figure against a stated claim of $165 million in total damages. When Whiteman switched lawyers and refiled, the demand was revised to $50 million. The Alexanders refused to pay at every stage.
For years after the alleged assault, Whiteman maintained a steady, voluntary, and often highly flirtatious stream of communication with the brothers. The documentary record, preserved in Facebook messages, tells a story that bears no resemblance to the one outlined in her complaint.
The Setting: Sir Ivan’s Castle
Before getting into the timeline of communications, it helps to establish where the alleged assault took place. Whiteman’s lawsuit claimed the incident occurred at a party hosted by Ivan Wilzig, the billionaire banker-turned-musician known publicly as “Sir Ivan,” at his sprawling castle in Water Mill in the Hamptons. The property, set on five acres, had been dubbed the “Playboy Mansion of the East Coast” by the press for years before the lawsuit was ever filed. Wilzig threw lavish annual parties there that were openly described by multiple media outlets including BuzzFeed News, the New York Post, Vice, and Thrillist as environments involving drugs, open sexual activity, and organized orgies. A 2016 BuzzFeed profile noted that “rumors had long swirled in the tabloids of nights filled with drugs and orgies” at the castle. A 2014 Thrillist piece described the property bluntly as a “sex dungeon mansion.” Page Six reported in August 2012 that a pool sex encounter at one of Wilzig’s parties had ended in a physical altercation among guests. This was the documented, publicly known environment of the party where Whiteman alleged she was assaulted. The Alexanders were among many guests who attended those events over the years.
The Timeline
To understand what happened, the sequence of events needs to be laid out exactly as the documents establish them.
May 2012: Whiteman alleges the assault took place at a Hamptons party. She was 32 years old at the time. The brothers were 24.
June 2012: One month after the alleged assault, Whiteman sent Oren Alexander a message about his upcoming birthday, writing: “Happy Birthday! I cant make it Monday night anymore, I’m sorry! I am banned from Toy. I have 2 gfs from australia in town, do u mind if they still come to your bday? They are lovely.” She was coordinating logistics for his birthday celebration and asking whether her friends could attend in her place.
Summer 2012: Whiteman reached out to Oren about a trip to the Hamptons, writing: “Heya! On way out to Hamptons now. We got a place in Watermill. What’s happening tonight? Come have a party at ours then castle maybe?! What’s ur cell?” She was inviting him to her rental home and asking for his phone number. This was the same area where she alleged she had been assaulted against her will just months earlier.
2012-2014: Over the following two years, Whiteman maintained a pattern of initiating contact with the brothers that, by the end, had taken on the character of borderline stalking. The messages grew significantly more explicit over time. In one message sent to Oren, Whiteman wrote in graphic detail about her physical desire for him, describing her own arousal and explicitly stating what she wanted to do with him sexually. The Daily Mail, which published excerpts of the messages in July 2025, described them as “raunchy” and noted they were sent entirely at Whiteman’s initiative. She also sent photographs of herself in various states of undress, including lingerie images taken in a mirror. She invited the brothers on a trip to Aspen. At one point, after Whiteman sent yet another unsolicited message, Oren responded by asking her directly whether she was delusional. She consistently initiated contact, maintaining a dynamic that was entirely at odds with her later claims of severe trauma and avoidance.
2013: Whiteman had a consensual sexual encounter with Alon Alexander. Sources indicate that this encounter involved Whiteman, Alon, and a female friend of Whiteman’s. There is a photograph from that evening showing the two women lying half-naked in bed together, kissing. Sources close to Oren Alexander indicate that he never had sex with Kate Whiteman at any point.
Early July 2022: Whiteman used Facebook Messenger’s “unsend” feature to systematically delete the dozens of messages she had exchanged with the brothers between 2011 and 2014. According to court filings, she deleted the messages after the Alexanders had already taken screenshots of key exchanges, intending to download the full archive at a later date. The Alexanders were able to salvage enough of the record to document the pattern of communication. The Alexanders’ answer and counterclaims, filed in November 2022, stated plainly: “Whiteman was caught attempting to destroy dozens of messages that she exchanged with the Alexanders on Facebook in the days and months before and after the date of her alleged rape, which tell an entirely different story from the one alleged in the Complaint.”
March 11, 2022: Whiteman filed a Summons with Notice publicly naming the Alexanders as defendants, accusing them of battery of a sexual nature, including claims under 18 U.S.C. § 1591, the federal sex trafficking statute.
August 30, 2022: The Derek Smith Law Group, Whiteman’s attorneys, submitted their mediation statement ahead of a mediation scheduled for September 6, 2022. In it, they laid out their damages calculation: “$15 million in compensatory damages for being raped by Alon and Oren Alexander” and “$150 million in punitive damages.” Their stated settlement position: “We feel a fair settlement in this case would be in the neighborhood of $35 million.”
The Alexanders refused to pay.
The Alexanders’ Response
The Alexanders’ legal team, represented by Terrence Oved and Andrew Urgenson of Oved & Oved LLP, did not hold back in their own mediation submission. They described Whiteman’s lawsuit as “a sham” and documented the pattern of messages she had sent the brothers in the years following the alleged assault. Their preliminary statement in the answer and counterclaims read:
“Whiteman’s accusations are shockingly false and defamatory. Her entire Complaint is a patently frivolous work of fiction facilitated by a law firm that the courts have sanctioned at least three times for misconduct in the past two years alone.”
The filing noted that the Derek Smith Law Group had been sanctioned in at least three separate federal cases for misconduct related to evidence spoliation and discovery abuses, including cases where courts found the firm had “failed to take sufficient steps to ensure that its client preserved evidence.”
The Alexanders also pointed out that when they knew Whiteman, she went by the alias “Kaitie Louiss” and claimed to be an Australian citizen in New York on a visa. The answer stated that “despite alleging that she was not romantically interested in either of them and that she would always decline their constant advances, the text messages that Whiteman thought she destroyed plainly reveal that she was the one who aggressively pursued the Alexanders.”
As their attorney Jason Goldman later told the Daily Mail in July 2025:
“Ms. Whiteman’s false allegations are contradicted by her own messages, the same ones she tried to delete just prior to litigation. In reality, she compulsively pursued the Alexanders for years after the alleged incident, behaving in a manner that even the most pliable victims’ expert would have trouble spinning.”
Goldman also addressed the brothers’ decision not to settle: “Despite having the means to silence her, they stood on integrity, refusing to pay a single penny, even when it would cost them their reputation, careers and freedom.”
Derek Smith Fires Whiteman as a Client
The mediation failed to produce a settlement. The Alexanders held firm. Sometime after that, the Derek Smith Law Group parted ways with Whiteman as a client.
On March 15, 2023, Derek Smith sent a formal notice to the Alexanders’ attorneys at Greenberg Traurig and Oved & Oved asserting a statutory attorneys’ lien on any recovery in the case. The letter, addressed to Paul Schafhauser at Greenberg Traurig and Andrew Urgenson at Oved & Oved, read:
“Please be advised that the Derek Smith Law Group, PLLC hereby asserts its attorneys’ lien on any recovery, whether by judgement or settlement, rendered in the above captioned matter for its attorneys’ fees and costs incurred by and through our representation of Kate Whiteman in this matter.”
The lien letter signaled that the firm had withdrawn from the case and was protecting its financial interest in any future recovery. Whiteman was now without her original legal team.
The Demand Escalates
Whiteman subsequently retained new counsel, the firm of Torgan Cooper & Aaron, P.C., led by Evan Torgan. She also refiled her complaint under a new index number, 952316/2023, in the Supreme Court of New York, County of New York.
On March 28, 2024, the Ferraro Law Firm filed a formal Request for Supplemental Demand for Relief on behalf of the Alexanders, pursuant to CPLR 3017(c), demanding that Whiteman specify in writing the total damages she was seeking within 15 days.
On April 1, 2024, both sides entered into a second stipulation. Torgan Cooper & Aaron and the Ferraro Law Firm agreed to extend the Alexanders’ deadline to answer, move, or otherwise respond to the complaint through May 31, 2024. As part of the agreement, the Alexanders waived any defenses related to improper or defective service of process. The stipulation was signed by Evan Torgan and Jonathan Tabar for Whiteman, and by James L. Ferraro and Natalia M. Salas for the Alexanders.
Meanwhile, Ivan Wilzig’s attorneys at Greenberg Traurig were moving in a different direction. On April 30, 2024, Wilzig served a Demand for Change of Place of Trial, requesting that the case be transferred from New York County to Suffolk County, where Wilzig resided. On May 15, 2024, Paul H. Schafhauser of Greenberg Traurig filed a supporting affirmation noting that Whiteman was “currently residing in Australia,” that Wilzig was a resident of Suffolk County, and that both Alon and Oren Alexander had resided in Florida since at least 2021. Whiteman filed no affidavit in response to the demand.
On April 10, 2024, Torgan Cooper & Aaron responded with a one-page filing stating simply: “Plaintiff deems herself entitled to an amount not less than $50 million.”
The demand had grown by $15 million from the original Derek Smith position. The Alexanders again refused to pay.
Resident_716 and the Reddit Campaign
While the legal battle played out in private, Whiteman was active online. On Reddit, under the username Resident_716, she posted in the r/Miami subreddit asking whether anyone had information about the Alexanders or could locate the old fake blog post and the supposed Miami Herald article. “Oren & Alon Alexander Rape trial; does anyone have any info or these articles? They had everything taken down....” the post read. She was searching for the fabricated 2009 Blogspot article that had been removed from Google search results years earlier.
The Reddit posts drew responses. One commenter, claiming to have worked at Kent Security, wrote: “I worked for Kent security years ago and came across the article of what occurred in Miami. That slimeball Alon has the same title of the blog that talked about the rape case but changed it to work in his favor, on his site. He’s a real shit bag. He would hit on the secretary’s that worked in the office. No wonder he would always hire woman for the NY office.” The comment treated the fake blog as a real news article, which was exactly the effect the fabricated post had been designed to produce.
Around the same time, Whiteman was privately messaging someone through Reddit’s direct message function. In those exchanges, she shared her Australian phone number, +61415922239, and wrote: “I’m actually in Australia now. Yes! Ivan just watched and let it happen!”
In those same private messages, Whiteman made clear the tensions that were developing between the accusers. The "Rebecca" she referred to was Rebecca Mandel, a second woman who had filed her own lawsuit against the Alexanders through the same law firm just a day after Whiteman's summons was filed. She wrote: "Rebecca is extremely high strung! And wanting to try take credit for everything... when I've been working on this for over 3 years!!! Her husband is trying to control the narrative and get all political things involved because the Alexander's donate to Jewish defence force and they shouldn't really be even suing the Alexander's who are donating. My lawyer did not want to print what the husband wanted as the jury is likely to be Palestinian."
She continued in the same private exchange: “Rebecca is trying to use the media coverage to get political messages across! It’s really disturbing. Evan shut her down. This is about us girls! Not politics.” She also accused Mandel of leaking information to the press: “Rebecca leaked this to the media! Trying to take credit. She is such an idiot. Now they might flee!! She has not even been in talks with the feds herself!”“
The messages show a fractured coalition of accusers. Whiteman positioned herself as the central figure who had been “working on this for over 3 years” and resented others for attempting to share the spotlight or steer the narrative in directions she did not approve of.
The private messages also shed light on how the accusers viewed their own coordination. When another user suggested to Whiteman, “Seems like the only evidence they have is them coming together and matching there stories,” Whiteman responded directly: “We have evidence! The three or four of us together is evidence. Plus one of the other girls has a witness. Two witnesses. All our stories together are evidence.”
Sources close to the brothers say the Alexanders had never heard of Rebecca Mandel prior to the lawsuit. They have no record of any digital communications with her and cannot place her in the same room as them at any point in their lives.
The Cold Email Campaign
Whiteman’s outreach was not limited to Reddit. On June 1, 2023, she sent an email from her personal iCloud address, katelouise24@icloud.com, to a prominent Miami businesswoman in the Alexanders’ broader social and professional circle. The email read: “Hello! Just wondering if you could please give me some more information below? So I can compare to some other issues? Which I can also tell you about? Regarding the Alexander Twins.” Along with the message, she attached a photograph of a link to the fake 2009 blog article. She was circulating it again, this time by email, to people connected to the brothers, attempting to solicit information and build a network of individuals who might corroborate or amplify her account.
The Pivot to the Fake Blog
Faced with exculpatory Facebook messages and a documented history of consensual interaction, Whiteman’s legal team needed leverage. They needed something damaging enough that the brothers would pay to keep it quiet.
They found it in the fake 2009 Blogspot article. In their August 30, 2022 mediation statement, the Derek Smith Law Group explicitly invoked the fabricated post as if it were a legitimate piece of journalism. The statement read: “As for the Alexander twins, we are also in the process of obtaining an article from the Miami Herald entitled, ‘Two North Miami Beach Teenagers Acquitted of Rape Charges.’ We also intend to identify the alleged victim in that case and produce her as an additional witness for Ms. Whiteman.”
There was no such Miami Herald article. There never had been. The article they were “in the process of obtaining” was the same anonymous Blogspot post that a court had already determined was fabricated and traced to a hidden Rocketmail account registered under a fictitious name. Derek Smith Law Group was threatening to introduce a fake news article as evidence in a civil proceeding and use it to identify and produce a witness. The Alexanders’ legal team later described this in their own mediation statement as part of a broader extortion scheme.
The fabricated story about a 2003 rape and a fake Miami Herald article had been deleted from Google search results in 2014. The brothers thought it was gone forever. But it was resurrected and folded into the litigation strategy. The threat of making that fake article public again, of attaching it to a lawsuit that was now a matter of public record, could be enough to destroy the Alexanders’ careers and reputations in the real estate world Oren had spent years building.
After Derek Smith Law Group sent its lien letter in March 2023, Whiteman retained new counsel: the firm of Torgan Cooper & Aaron, P.C., led by Evan Torgan. On November 22, 2023, Torgan filed a Summons with Notice on Whiteman’s behalf in the Supreme Court of New York, County of New York, under index number 952316/2023. The summons named Oren Alexander, Alon Alexander, and Ivan Wilzig as defendants and alleged sexual battery arising from the May 2012 incident at Wilzig’s Water Mill property. November 22, 2023 was the final day of the lookback window created by New York’s Adult Survivors Act, which had temporarily allowed adults to sue over alleged sexual offenses regardless of when the conduct occurred. Both of Torgan’s filings that week came in under that deadline.
On January 30, 2024, a process server arrived at Alon Alexander’s home in Miami Beach. Alon was not there. His wife, Shani Alexander, answered the door. She was served on his behalf. A copy of the summons was also mailed to the address, marked “Personal and Confidential.”
The same process server, Mitchell Trujillo, returned five weeks later. On March 5, 2024, he arrived at Oren Alexander’s home in Miami Beach. Oren was not there either. His wife, Kamila Alexander, answered the door. She was served on his behalf. A copy was mailed to the address the following day, March 6, 2024, again marked “Personal and Confidential.”
What happened on the Ivan Wilzig side of the case was also notable. On February 13, 2024, Torgan Cooper & Aaron and Greenberg Traurig LLP, the firm representing Wilzig, entered into a formal stipulation. Under its terms, Wilzig acknowledged service of the summons, waived any defenses related to improper service, and was given an extended deadline through May 31, 2024 to demand the formal complaint. The stipulation was a quiet but significant detail: Wilzig’s lawyers were cooperating with the process rather than contesting it, and the same firm, Greenberg Traurig, that had represented the Alexanders in the earlier mediation was now representing the man who hosted the party where the alleged assault occurred.
On February 20, 2024, the Alexanders filed their own response to the summons. The Ferraro Law Firm, P.A., a Miami-based firm led by James L. Ferraro, filed a Notice of Appearance and Demand for Complaint on behalf of Alon and Oren Alexander, formally entering the case and demanding that Whiteman serve the full complaint within 20 days. The notice was filed with an express reservation of all of the brothers’ rights, defenses, objections, and claims.
What happened next is one of the most striking details in the entire case.
The coordinated legal campaign was not limited to Whiteman alone. On November 24, 2023 — two days after Whiteman’s summons and also within the final days of the Adult Survivors Act window — Torgan filed a second Summons with Notice, this one on behalf of a woman named Rebecca Mandel, under index number 952356/2023. Mandel’s summons alleged sexual assault and battery in “September, October 2010” at the defendants’ residence at 55 W 26th Street in New York. Like Whiteman’s summons, it was filed by Torgan Cooper & Aaron, P.C. Unlike Whiteman’s case, it named only Oren and Alon Alexander as defendants — not Ivan Wilzig.
On March 8, 2024, Torgan Cooper & Aaron filed two separate formal complaints in the Supreme Court of New York, County of New York, on the same day. The first was Whiteman’s full complaint, under index number 952316/2023. The second was Mandel’s formal complaint, under index number 952356/2023. Both complaints named Oren and Alon Alexander as defendants. Both were filed by the same law firm. Both were filed on the same day.
The parallel structure extended to the procedural filings as well. On April 1, 2024 — the same day the Whiteman-Alexander stipulation was filed — Torgan Cooper & Aaron and the Ferraro Law Firm entered into an identical stipulation in the Mandel case, under index number 952356/2023. The terms were the same: the Alexanders’ deadline to respond was extended through May 31, 2024, and they waived any defenses related to improper service. The same four attorneys signed both stipulations on the same day.
The coordinated filing was not a coincidence. Whiteman’s private Reddit messages had already made clear that she and Mandel were in communication and that Evan Torgan was coordinating their legal strategies. “Evan shut her down,” Whiteman had written of Mandel. “This is about us girls.”
Whiteman had complained privately that Mandel was difficult to work with and that tensions were running high between them. In one message, she wrote: “Pls keep between us but she was very difficult to work with. Was very disrespectful to Evan. Her husband was on the phone to Evan wanting him to write certain things in the press that he didn’t feel comfortable writing (more about politics).”
Those tensions appear to have had consequences. On July 18, 2024, Mandel filed a Consent to Substitute Attorney in her case, replacing Torgan Cooper & Aaron with Simmons Hanly Conroy LLP, represented by Jayne Conroy. The substitution was filed with the New York County Clerk on August 1, 2024. Mandel had parted ways with the same lawyer who had filed both cases on the same day just months earlier. Whiteman’s private messages confirmed the split: “Rebecca was so high maintenance & stressful, so we r just relieved now we parted ways.”
The simultaneous public filing brought both cases into the public record at the exact same moment. The civil lawsuits were no longer simply private disputes over decade-old allegations. They had become a coordinated public campaign, built on a foundation that included a fabricated internet post from 2009, and carrying a combined financial demand that had grown to $50 million.
(In Part 3, we will detail how the fake blog was explicitly weaponized in the mediation proceedings, how it appeared in Whiteman's psychological evaluation, how Ivan Wilzig's attorneys called the entire case "extortion," and how the media completely misrepresented the situation and encouraged a pile-on that took on a life of its own.)
vindictive bitches🐍
I don't voluntarily consume celebrity gossip but you make it compelling and illustrate the injustice and irrationality permeating New York State.