Eli Beer’s grotesque story about a baby cut from its mother’s stomach on October 7 has now collapsed entirely under scrutiny. Multiple people directly connected to the massacre at Kibbutz Be’eri, the community that endured some of the worst atrocities that day, have confirmed that no such incident occurred. Those who lived through and helped document the horror told me plainly: “We know what happened. This story is not true.” Their testimony carries the weight of firsthand endurance and direct involvement, not rumor.
What makes the collapse of this claim particularly egregious is how Beer chose to present it. His most viral lie involved a pregnant woman whose unborn child allegedly died after the mother. Standing before the Republican Jewish Coalition in Las Vegas, Beer described what he claimed to have witnessed personally: a woman who was “four months pregnant” whose stomach was “opened up” by Hamas terrorists who “took out the baby and stabbed a little tiny baby in front of her.” He did not frame this as hearsay or unverified testimony. He said it with the authority of someone on the ground, insisting that he had seen it with his ow